Arizona Paint Supply

Dunn‑Edwards color · mixed in Benjamin Moore

Pigeonhole DEBN57

Benjamin Moore already has the formula for Pigeonhole, so we mix the exact color at our North Scottsdale counter, in the line the surface needs. Same color, better paint. If you’d rather choose one of Benjamin Moore’s own colors, the five closest are below. Pigeonhole is currently approved in 1 Arizona HOA scheme we track.

About this color

Recommended surfaces
  • — Exterior body — within all of the Scottsdale and Paradise Valley limits, and the Arizona HOA sweet spot
  • — Garage doors and exterior accents
  • — Feature and accent walls
  • — Cabinet bodies

Sheen: Matte or eggshell on walls; satin holds up better on garage doors and high-touch trim. Flat on exterior stucco.

DEBN57 Pigeonhole is a mid-tone, muted tan (LRV ≈ 33). Mid-tones are where most Arizona HOA bodies land, and where beige, tan, taupe and warm-gray exteriors blend with the Sonoran landscape. At LRV 33 it sits inside all three municipal overlay caps: Scottsdale ESL (35), Paradise Valley Hillside (38) and Scottsdale Foothills (40). Mid-tones run slightly warmer in west sun than lighter bodies, so we use Element Guard or Regal Select for any south or west elevation.

Which Benjamin Moore line?

Regal Select Exterior or Aura Exterior, in soft gloss

Front doors and shutters take the most direct sun and the most handling, and soft gloss is the finish we put on them. Regal Select Exterior holds a color like this well; Aura Exterior is worth it on a door that takes full afternoon sun. Bring the Benjamin Moore code from any of the five swatches above and we’ll mix that exact color at the counter.

Arizona HOAs that use Pigeonhole

Pick the Benjamin Moore that fits your job.

Bring the Dunn-Edwards code, your HOA scheme number or a Benjamin Moore code from the swatches above, and we’ll match the line to the job.

8340 E Raintree Dr, North ScottsdaleMon–Fri 6 am–6 pm · Sat 9 am–3 pmDirections